Exploring the Ancient Gods of Athas

,
#1

As I contemplate the deep history of Athas, I explore the reality of the gods of Athas, apart from the religious milieu created by the sorcerer-kings. Explanations and histories of these matters are needed when you lead the campaign into a deep tour of some of the cultures of Athas, especially the core Seven City-States. Gods and god-like beings from the Green Age are referenced very rarely but often enough in the lore to take a more in-depth look at the matter. Even if they are almost always unnamed, often enough these ‘divine’ beings seem to survive at least in legends, and that is why it is useful to know a little more about them, and to have some understanding if they are or ever were real, and if they were real, how much their reality comports with the myths told of them.

I will not presently attempt to present a thorough catalog, but for the sake of concision, I shall focus on available data that I recall from the core cities of the Tablelands:

Balic: “Ancient ancestors of modern Balikites developed an elaborate non-religious mythology of fictional parables, like fairy tales. This legendary world pervades all the city’s culture, drama, epic poetry, and music…” (Veiled Alliance, p. 32)
Comments: Greek mythology is all but stated here. A tastefully if fairly heavily modified port of Greek mythology is necessitated here. By in a fantasy world, how many of these myths actually exist, or at one time existed? I believe Tyrian and Balican culture (Roman and Greek) are related to one another, and otherwise that Balican culture or versions thereof are widespread, especially along the Silt Sea littoral and islands. Exploration of Balican mythology thus is of major interest for mapping out “gods” in Dark Sun.

Draj: Obviously its god-king dominates the religion, and we may suspect that reference to all other deities are likewise artifices developed by the sorcerer-king. However, like the rest of the sorcerer-kings, King Tec did seem to come from somewhere, leading a culture to Draj’s current location from somewhere likely quite far away from the Tablelands. Whatever gods might have lurked in this older culture before Tec established his rule over them, we cannot see, though obviously they are a port of Aztec culture, and we might consider a sub-strata of beliefs in the divine from that culture buried throughout much of their surviving mythology.

Giustenal: Taraskir the Lion is a lazy observation, as we are all quite familiar with this demigod-like being, who was probably an immortal/advanced being of some sort from the Green Age (I speculate there were an array of such beings throughout Athas in those times). However, during his own lifetime he did not believe himself to be a god, and a single reference in CbtSS (Campaign Book, p. 10) references he had his own god: “Originally, the temple was dedicated to a forgotten god worshiped by Taraskir and his followers.”

Gulg: The oba seems to have completely monopolized the divine portfolio in Gulg. Though spirits and such are recognized, none seem to have taken the identity of ‘god,’ at least to my knowledge.

Nibenay: As I may explore in a separate thread, Nibenese culture, being a fairly direct port of the Khmer Empire, implies the potential existence of deities or at least god-like monsters in the past, though there are not direct examples from the lore, per se. But the Naggaramakkum, for example, is obviously partly based on the fascinating inner palace of the Khmer King. The matter of the Khmer King mating with the naga-spirit-turned-woman every night atop his central tower in the inner palace is an interesting myth that compliments the Naggaramakkum very well, and we may wonder how if any such real-world myths might best support Nibenese cultural development in Dark Sun. Was there a god-like naga that Gallard supplanted at one point? Was Gallard himself responsible for the seven-headed naga legend (if you wish to import that element)? Was such a naga lord a powerful demigod-like being, akin Taraskir the Lion? These are interesting religious themes to explore, or ignore, if you elect to port over much of Khmer culture to Nibenay.

The Ivory Triangle, one of the best DS supplements, does let us know that current Nibenese culture was overlayed upon a more ancient one: “All around the city is evidence of the ancient culture that Nibenay was built upon. Modern Nibenese construction surrounds and intermingles with ancient ruins and edifices. Some of these old sites are abandoned, but others remain occupied by the city’s masses.” (CSoN, p. 2) Nibenay seems a city and culture ripe with possibilities to explore legendary monsters and demi-gods from the remote past that may or may not be rooted in some sort of cultural reality.

Raam: Skipping over the obvious topic of Badna, which seems wholly an artifice of Abalach-Re, we are left with an Indian port, I think specifically that of the Mughal Empire. In this, it is hard to ignore an obvious and strong mytho-cultural link to Nibenay, as the Khmer Empire had major arteries of cultural influence from India. But what are we to find in Raam? The upadna to me are rather direct parallels to Buddhist stupas, which have been obviously crassly co-opted by the Grand Vizier. What gods or religion were these stupas once dedicated to? In my opinion, Raam is one of the least developed city-states, which is a shame, as it seems it could be quite fascinating. Bottom line, to me it needs a lot of work. Is there a sub-strata of the Vedic gods buried in the cultural mythos of Raam? Can we hear in their songs and stories parallel elements of the Rigveda and Mahabharata, tastefully translated to Athas in a not too direct fashion? Some early ideas to explore…

Tyr: The Roman cultural milieu is strong in Tyr. Kalak seems to have erased most any living memory of Green Age gods, but as we well know, reference to such beings are buried beneath the city, deep in its history. The Crimson Shrine is one of the best explorations of divine beings in all of Dark Sun lore, and I explore this below. We might suspect some more Roman and even Greek (via, Balic, in the Greco-Roman tradition) buried in the Tyrian cultural sub-strata, but by the same token Tyr seems to be among the most unique and wholly “independent” cultures of the Tablelands, and is a good model and reminder for how you might best follow certain real-world cultural threads without being too crass and direct (Tyr is a slight parallel to Rome, but only a little, and only in certain ways… always tasteful).

Urik: More than perhaps any other of the classic Seven Cities, the sorcerer-king of Urik seems to have wholly erased any gods that once existed for the people of Hamanu. No references to such beings in this cultural milieu are known to me. Much like Draj, Urik was heavily shaped by its king, and he seems to have crowded out any competing mythology.

Initial Review of Lore on Green Age Gods

From what we know of the gods of the Green Age, it seems that what reality and power they had was fueled only by the power of extraordinary belief. The gods may not actually exist, but the human belief in one could manifest in some of the traditional miracles of the AD&D multiverse, as demonstrated by the unliving knights of the Crimson Shrine beneath Tyr. “Faith keeps the candles burning,” Ktandeo explained to us about the candles of that temple, and mentions not the power (nor the name) of the eagle-headed, snake-tailed, bat-winged god depicted in the stained-glass.

But are we certain that gods on Athas are never affirmed in the canon? Denning quipped in an interview:

*Eric Anondson: “I know that no material was ever going to be published to declare whether or not gods ever existed on Athas. Could you enlighten how this situation worked for the raaig and the wraith of Undertyr?” *

Troy: “Sorry, I don’t think Tim and I are ready to say whether gods ever existed on Athas or not. (We’re STILL arguing about it!)”

There are also Denning’s comments in Dragon 173, p. 21: “Who can say what happened to these ancient deities? Did they ever exist? Did they die? Did they leave, or simply fade away as mortal spirits do now now? This is one of the great secrets that necromancy stands to answer.”

Although my general rule regarding the Denning novels is that when his characters state a thing it is to be taken as a truism for the setting, these above statements color the important comments from the Verdant Passage of Ktandeo regarding the ancient gods:

“The god can’t be still alive. Kalak would never stand for that beneath his city,” Sadira objected…

"You don’t understand, Ktandeo said, pulling himself completely upright. "The gods of the ancients aren’t sorcerer-kings. They were much more powerful. And those who worshiped them did so with all their hearts. Not the way the templars worship Kalak.

"What happened to these ancient gods? Agis asked.

"Ktandeo shook his head. “Like all glories of the past they faded away. No one knows why.”

I believe Denning took a step back from this assertion after Verdant Passage, for never again are we told that the gods of old had a certain reality and power. In this passage alone we are to take it that there indeed were gods, but the mystery is not in their existence, but rather what happened to them.
However, this is stand alone, and a firm no positivist reference to gods is adopted thereafter by Denning and all other DS authors. Certainly by the time of City By the Silt Sea, a more hardline outlook came to fore:

While he may eventually have his revenge on the sorcerer-kings who killed him, Dregoth will never become a god-at least not on Athas. Athas has never had any gods, and it never will. Why this is may never be completely understood, but the fact is that the conduits that allow gods (or powers, as they’’re called elsewhere) to draw strength from their worshipers simply don’’t exist on Athas. No matter what Dregoth does, he won’’t be able to change that fact —and he isn’’t even aware that this is a problem. Without these spiritual conduits, divine power can’t be attained. (CBtSS, Campaign Book, 90)

But what more can we gather regarding the deities of the Green Age. There actually is more lore, which perhaps I will explore further in this thread. Hopefully these explorations bear fruit for your own campaigns, which some of the secrets, and the rich flare they might present to your players, may breathe rich life into the setting.

3 Likes
#2

Difficult questions but I may have an answer. The answer may be completely different depending on the campaign. For example, in one campaign, the gods previously existed. In other campaigns the gods may have never existed at all, or they may have existed in a different form, such as powerful beings or entities that were not truly divine.

If the gods did exist in the past, there are several possibilities for what happened to them:

  1. They may have faded away as belief in them dwindled. Without the power of faith to sustain them, they simply ceased to be.
  2. They could have been destroyed or killed, perhaps in conflicts with each other or with powerful mortals like the sorcerer-kings.
  3. The gods may have chosen to leave Athas, either out of disappointment with mortals, or to escape some cataclysm. They may still exist somewhere else.
  4. The nature of Athas itself may have changed in a way that made it inhospitable or inaccessible to divine beings. Perhaps the spiritual conduits mentioned in City by the Silt Sea were destroyed.

In a campaign where the gods never truly existed, the myths and legends about them could still play an important role. These stories may have been inspired by real events and people, like powerful psionicists or beings from other planes. Faith in these mythic figures could still manifest real power.

Ultimately, the true history of Athas’ gods comes down to the individual Dark Sun campaign. The setting is intentionally mysterious about such metaphysical questions. This allows each DM to decide what best fits their vision of Athas and the stories they want to tell. Whether the gods were real, and what became of them, is for you and your players to determine.

3 Likes
#3

there is two positions about gods on Athas, the first (seems yours) if that gods exists in the past on Athas,
but the second (and more possible, according to either 2e or 4e lore -who are different many ways-) is that gods -as D&D game understand those creatures or powers- NEVER -you read well, never- existed on the face of Athas, as they cannot reach Athas from the outer planes (that also includes evil gods and evil races such as demons and devils) as in Athas there are no planar connection to those places
That does not means that Dregoth cannot summon demons -who actually happens-, but that the godlike abilities of planars such as gods and, demigods does not function on Athas. That also means that abilities tied to the home plane of demons, devils, aasimon (angels), slaadi and others also does not function on Athas, like their gate abilities. Also that warlock pact patrons cannot reach Athas. In fact ANY abilities tied to the outer planes does not function on Athas

2 Likes
#4

I compiled a pdf listing comments on gods on Athas. Here is the link Comments on Gods in all Dark sun products.pdf - Google Drive

You will find there are several types of gamers who believe:

  1. Athas never had gods, and these religions were always fake, only elemental worship existed.
  2. Athas once had gods but they are all gone, no one knows how or why.
  3. The truth is unknowable and although temples, and other places of worship as well as names of ancient beings exist, along with undead who still worship them. No one knows if they were actual gods or powerful elemental lord or something else entirely. The past has been lost to the sands of time, and any who know are not talking.
  4. Or they cherry pick the books and statements and ignore the inconvenient ones to build their narrative of their world view on gods.
6 Likes
#5

I like the idea that there may have been gods in the distant past. That’s what I speculate on with my Dregoth in the outer planes fan fiction. In this scenario, the universe that contains Athas is the original universe, while the universe of the other campaign settings like the Forgotten Realms is the new universe. The Gray, in this fan fiction, was created to prevent the universe of Athas from dissolving completely.

4 Likes
#6

Your compilation is excellent Xelu. Thank you for posting this. Quite useful. Indeed, I think your highlight from Air, Earth, Fire, Water is indeed probably right on target with the appropriate original tone for the setting. Props for zeroing in on this:

“If there is any truth to the rumors, the truth is now as irrelevant as the stony structures of the ancients that sometimes break the the surface of the blasted Athasian landscape.”

3 Likes
#7

1a. Athas never had Deities. However, there were belief systems that developed into religions but the entities that they worshipped were Primordial Spirits of the Land (creatures far surpassing the RAW Spirit of the Land statblock). They were the original Elemental Vortices, Athasian versions of the Elemental Princes (of Admixture rather than purity). They had personalities and ‘racial identities’ but were not Creator Deities, just sentient metaphysical blobs of elemental mass that adopted the beliefs that their observers assigned to them through worship. The Way and Magic both created fractures in the personified elemental amalgams which created schizms in their cults and divided them into lesser beings which were just facets of their previous glory. They’ve been Spirits of the Land since the Vortices that remained were stolen while time degrades their power and memories of their lost greatness

4 Likes
#8

I like to think gods on Athas were a thing, my working theory on this problem is this:
During the Blue Age the conduits required for the existence of gods were in a nascent state or out of whack, while the conduits linked to the elemental planes were already fully formed. The use of the Pristine Tower to kill the brown tide either supercharged them or shifted them into place, and allowed for gods to be formed during the Green Age, only for the third use of the PT by Rajaat/champions to kill the flow of power, either by destroying the less stable divine conduits (as they had to pierce through the gray in order to reach the outer planes) or shifting them out of place once again, where they decayed and were destroyed completely by the Gray.

Depending on the source, if it was Rajaat whose use of the PT to create the champions (as opposed to the champions later using it to turn themselves into 1st level dragons and Borys into a full one) changed the color of the sun, then he may tried (and succeeded) to kill 2 birds with one stone- creating immortal champions and killing the gods of his enemies who might have interfered with his plans.

The living vortices could may well be the last remnants of these divine conduits

3 Likes
#9

I follow the multifarious Athas’s model. That means there are various possible histories, including Rajaat but also possibly excluding him or altering his background or nature.

One intriguing possibility is that the Sorcerer Monarchs were once champions of the true deities, whom they betrayed and cast out. Thus the powers of the Sorcerer Monarchs are based on theft. In doing this, the Sorcerer Monarchs denied Athasians the possibility of being reborn in the higher realms (the Outer Planes) as immortal souls. Instead their souls are dissolved in the Gray.

5 Likes
#10

That’s interesting redking. I am not familiar with your fan fiction. Where might I find this?

That’s interesting, your proposed notion of an “original universe”. One of the better explanations I have come across. I do think the cosmology of Athas is important to any deeper exploration of the setting. It comes up too readily when you go beyond the surface level in game. To me it needs more exploring. I think it was Raddu who pursued the Crimson Sphere concept, and although I admit I am doubtful to admit many of his more far-flung concepts into my version of the setting, I do much appreciate his willingness to explore such topics, and I shall be looking to apply the best of his work there. Such explorations help plumb some important depths that are worthy of a player’s interest.

3 Likes
#11

Most of the posts in this thread. I think you have already seen the first. The rest detail Dregoth’s adventures in the Outer Planes.

#12

Another possibility comes to mind with a little knowledge of the Dawn War and understanding DnD cosmology.

Part of the origin story of the Forgotten Realms includes a massive war between primordials and the gods. This ended in the severing of Abeir and Toril into two separate worlds.

Toril like many Prime Worlds of DnD is cosmologically coterminous with the astral plane. This allows a conduit for the worship of gods and connection to the outer planes. Arcane magic typically needs this connection to the astral as well (thus accounting for Athas’ particular problem with arcane magic).

Abeir was out of planar alignment with the astral and became a “shadow world” of Toril. The world of Abeir was completely cut off from the gods (sounds very familiar) and if I understand correctly a strong connection to the elemental planes (also sounds very familiar).

If we can imply that something similar happened on Athas during its ancient history, then it can explain a lot and open up several possibilities.

  1. The gods both did AND did not exist on Athas.

One of the things about the Dawn War in DnD is that it has happened, it is happening, and it will continue to happen across space/time… Both forwards and backwards… At the same time… Because of altered realities, altered time, and EVEN a possible division of Athas into 2 worlds; there could be ruins of a temple to a god that doesn’t exist on Athas that DOES exist on Athas twin. If the Dawn War came to Athas, then this could be the answer to why the evidence of gods is so confusing.

  1. Rjaat is responsible for moving Athas to its current cosmology.

In this scenario, Rjaat wanted to cut Athas off from the gods. Seeing as how gods of the various races would likely try and stop him in his genocidal quest, this is extremely plausible. We also know Athas’ sun has been severely aged by the combined power of the Pristine Tower and Black Lens (which something like this would likely cause). The argument against this would be about preserving/defiling being taught by Rjaat… but a counterargument would be who better than Rjaat to figure out how arcane magic works in the changed world? And at some point, residents of Athas would forget about an older world that existed without defiling.

  1. The Shadow of Athas

If Athas is a split world like Abeir and Toril are (or were depending on which edition you are playing) the obvious question is what has become of it? Is it destroyed? Does it still have a green sun? Is it another campaign world basically like Forgotten Realms? What would happen if someone tried to merge the two worlds? It certainly puts a different spin on the Dregoth Ascending adventure.

3 Likes
#13

An interesting proposition Blackwolf. And welcome aboard, by the way.

I admit I would prefer not to ascribe such power to Rajaat, to banish the gods so.

It is a great mystery, and a deliberate one from the original designers. Not knowing for certain makes in-depth design of the ancient world very challenging, but the great mystery of it all seems to contribute greatly to why we like this setting so much, and why it has so endured.

2 Likes
#14

The theory I ended up putting together was something along the lines of:

  • Connections to the Outer Planes was possible at one time.
  • Divine power is/was possible at one time.

Now the speculation of why, if gods were possible, were they not present becomes interesting.

Result 1: The gods are dead, long live the new gods.
If the thought that gods had to be worshiped for their power to exist reigns, then that means likely due to the age of High Magic and Psionic potential, people may have thought they did not need gods as much. Then when the series of apocalyptic conflicts started, people either abandoned the faith, or they were exterminated systematically, leaving too few people that believed to sustain the gods of Athas.

Due to the lack of sustainable magic on Athas, the tenuous reach to continually drag the Outer Planes creatures in would become more and more unwieldy. Especially when the elemental planes are right there! With a lack of faith and difficulty of actual execution, the knowledge and practice of such things could see a decline - especially if a deity required thousands of worshipers now was starving for worship in this Sphere. They would be better off heading to another Pantheon while they still had gas in the tank!

Result 2: The Gray pushed them away.
The cosmology of Athas has a realm of Infinite possibility in the Black. The Gray is endless as well, ending to a place of stagnation. Due to the series of wars, it plane of Souls just continued to grow and dissolve where the sphere has its own sort of “Wall of the Faithless”, eventually losing their identity and becoming part of the shell that protects the plane by simply being such a force of innertia. A god would have to look past an infinite stagnation of a sphere that genocided most of its races, past all the wars and death that have accumulated, to realize that there’s something still alive out there. Gods that would have been around may still be out there, if you could find them in the Gray, trapped by the sea of souls.

Result 3: A bit of both!
Now this is my favored option but strays more from the source. Using the Crimson Sphere book from Athas.org, I understood the concept that Rajaat may have created a massive barrier to protect the Sphere from the outside. What if he in turn, wielded such calamities to in sure that the other outsiders, those that would try to meddle and rule over this plane, inspire such injustices or be moved to interfere, simply couldn’t? By killing their followers in the cleansing wars, and doing it in such vast numbers, the gods could not directly interfere. They’d lose their powers with lack of faith, eventually becoming little motes of power and memory (that could eventually be used to create the Shards of the Zodiac).

The dead are a wasteland of misery and agony, that while it might entice the occasional fiend, is in such a stagnant area that they would become trapped trying to feast on the souls. Remnants too angry and furious over their own misery to ever let a fiend go because finally they have something to express their agony on.

2 Likes
#15

I like the 4e answer (note I haven’t fully read the material, and I may be misremembering what I do remember).

In 4e cosmology, there was a war between the gods (who wanted to use the world’s created by the primordials) and the primordials (who enjoy creating AND destroying worlds, and want to wipe the slate clean so they can make the next world). Most of these wars ended with the gods winning, but with enough primordial turncoats that paths to the elements remain open. (Then the wild spirits, the primals, push the gods out and prevent direct intervention by both the gods and the primordials.)

In Dark Sun, the primordials won the war so well that the gods were pushed out and the links to the Astral were cut. I don’t know the material enough to know if the wild spirits, the primals, pushed out the primordials.

It does open up a fun possibility, though. What if the wild spirits aren’t strong enough to keep out the primordials any longer?

#16

Let us recall the simplest possibility of all: Seal Crystal Sphere.

Even if the spell was introduced to us via FR, that does not mean it could not exist elsewhere, or otherwhen, in the D&D setting. However that spell (11th level) only sealed all the portals to a sphere, which prevented spelljamming ships access… so it is likely that a 12 or 13th level version was used that locked out planar access entirely.

The most likely answer is that someone at sometime in the past sealed Athas’ crystal sphere.

4 Likes
#17

Let me get out Dragon-Kings; so, a Pscionist or an Elemental Cleric, and be a past, “God”, which is pretty much an immortal-being with lots of power; as close to a god from Legends & Lore as possible. I pictured the Green-Age, an age not of Dragon-Kings, but of Elemental-Kings.

2 Likes
#18

There also could be made an argument that Athas itself may be some type of primordial.

Other worlds have an energy field of some type that allows arcane magic, but Athas requires you to connect to either it or another power source.

On other worlds, druids despite worshipping nature are getting their spells from gods. Yet again, the druid requires a connection to Athas.

Also, the primordials tended to have a strong connection to the elemental planes.

Advanced beings of Athas…could it be that Athas is a primordial turning itself into a crucible to create more primordials?

3 Likes
#19

The last campaign I ran was Athas, pre-Dark Sun. A fairly large part of the storyline was an attempt to explore why Dark Sun had no gods and some of how Dark Sun came to be. I probably should have delved deeper into the lore way back then (2018-ish?) but for whatever reason I could never find much about the ancient times. There’s a fair overlap between parts of what I came up with and what I’m reading in this thread though, which is rather pleasing.

I started out with a race of gods or god-like beings called the Nephiliim who live in the space between planes, and use places like Athas to rear their young. Something went wrong this time, and 15 (comparatively) young gods were left to their own devices on a young Athas. Things didn’t go well, the battle between order and chaos causing continual devastation. So an elven civilisation came up with a plan to lock the gods away, which succeeded briefly. The attempt left almost all of the gods seriously angry, more devastation followed.

Sometime later, a race of giants picked up where the elves left off. With the help of one of the gods - one dedicated to a serious code of ethics that acknowledged the situation couldn’t continue, a fairly powerful magic user by the name of Rajaat, and a Sapphire dragon by the name of Metis, came up with a more permanent solution, locking all the gods away in a mountain range, with the prison maintained by the vigilance of the giants. The process involved creating a barrier between Athas and the rest of the planes that was essentially composed of the essence of the one god who helped.

Sometime later, over on Pyatha a young civilisation rises that has found flaws in the barrier (not knowing what the barrier was, just that it was there), that they can use to create stable, continent-wide portals that are used 24/7 for trade and travel. The downside was that this was weakening the giants, and let Rajaat steal the essence of one of the gods, which he then started experimenting with, attempting to siphon off the power and use it for his own ends.

Which is pretty much where the party came in. They figured a lot of this out in the end, and found a solution, though not a permanent one. I’ve been itching to patch as much of that as I can into the larger history of Athas for ages (being the primary reason I’ve ended up in this forum I think) because I’m currently working on the follow up campaign, which going to overlap the last campaign and takes some wildly non-canon paths to cover a few thousand years of history up to maybe somewhen around the first appearances of the sorcerer kings - though a couple of them have already made appearances as normal humans.

Should be fun.

2 Likes
#20

An interesting challenge for sure, and reminds me of a certain Nodwick strip from back in the day when the gang got visited by the “young new deity next door” lol. The matter of whether gods ever roamed Athas is a matter of what story one wants to tell, as I recall the original authors of the setting were split on the matter so definitely do what’s best for you and your tables enjoyment! Gives a new level of terror and pettiness to Rajaat for him to be a godling… and welcome to The Arena!

2 Likes