It seems to me that the obvious and unavoidable intent of Mr. Baker in the writing of the masterful Dragon’s Crown adventure set was that Merek the Wrong was another Champion of Rajaat. Indeed, as we point out in this thread, Merek refers to Hamanu as a peer. Indeed, the text refers to Merek as a “defiler warlord.” This was also the term used to describe Irikos in the Book of Artifacts, and as we all know, Irikos was assigned as the original Orc Plague, as Book of Artifacts makes perfectly clear.
That Merek is some sort of subordinate is not a tenable argument. Merek is described in Dragon’s Crown as commanding legions, and wielding dragon magic (10th level spells). “Defiler warlord” meant Champion of Rajaat at this early time in Dark Sun’s publishing history, and as Champion of Rajaat is an almost cult-like title likely only recognized within Rajaat’s inner circle, we ought not to expect many of their enemies to deign to use such a title, or even necessarily know of it.
Merek, like Irikos, is fascinating to me. And it is interesting that both Merek and Irikos were destroyed by rival preservers of the time, Merek by the defiling magic of Haakar at Akarakle, and Irikos by an unknown but obviously very powerful sorceress at Bodach. Many of us here in these forums over the years have preferred essentially god-like Champions of Rajaat, a la Lynn Abbey’s depiction of Hamanu in R&FoaDK. I have not favored this. Ascribing to them such radical power is outside of Troy Denning’s narrative, makes them all but unassailable to any PCs that might ever encounter them, and is well beyond the limits of their game mechanics, at least as the game might work in 2nd Edition.
The “defiler warlords” of Rajaat may have been ageless, but they were not immortal gods. At 21st level, their hit points were not yet off the charts, and may not even have yet broken 100 hp. Disasters and mortal mistakes were still risks, their PSP pool was not endless (and could be rather finite if pressed with many lesser psionic foes), and they could not employ endless 9th level spells, but rather had but a few. Poor generalship or overconfidence (as seems to have been the case with Irikos) could spell their end.
I ask, what race do we think Merek was assigned to terminate? Dragon’s Crown does not say, or I have missed a buried hint. But this notion that he was but a “captain”, or some other subordinate officer under a Champion, was absolutely not what Mr. Baker intended. No “captain”, in any sense, commands legions, plural. He was a Champion of Rajaat, plain and simple.
Obviously our sense of the timeline for Hamanu, being a latter-day Champion, feels off somewhat in the reading of Dragon’s Crown. Indeed, there is a mismatch. Retcondor however can swoop down, and suggest that the siege of Akarakle was much later in the history of the Cleansing Wars.