How are Psionics and Magic different (in setting)?

[redking]

@neujack

Elminster and Dracula could theoretically meet on Athas in my homebrew, but it would require an EXTREMELY good (and probably universe endangering) reason in the story.

After all, games should be about bringing enjoyment to the table for the players and the DM, not enforcing your highly particular vision of what the world must be onto everyone in attendance.

I discussed something similar here. My conclusion was that as long as it does not warp the setting, then anything goes.

Let’s say you have a player that really wants to play a warforged in Dark Sun. Why not let him? As long as you don’t have the Eberron baggage of a major war in which warforged were used, then a singular warforged out there won’t warp the setting. Maybe this warforged was created by a cleric or wizard with the craft construct feat. The point is that there are many ways to say yes that won’t compromise the vision of the DM or the integrity of the setting.