The Black Opal: The Reincarnation of Borys of Ebe

“How do you Borys isn’t dead?” Rikus demanded, stopping just beyond the wraith’s reach. “He could have died someplace else.”

“You know that cannot be,” she answered confidently.
“Why not?”
The wraith pointed at the dark opal in the broken lid of Rikus’s sarcophagus. “If you were dead, your spirit would have returned to light your gem.”

-Troy Denning, The Crimson Legion, p. 175

One of the great questions of post-Prism Pentad Athas: can Borys of Ebe be reincarnated?

As we all know, the black slime from the broken Scourge of Rkard dissolved the Dragon’s body. The Dragon therefor is no more. But did his soul survive? Did Rajaat somehow capture and consume or otherwise banish his soul?

As her body was destroyed in a similar way, the same question perhaps can be asked of Abalach-re. But in Borys’ case, we have this very interesting scene cited above, from when Rikus is trapped in the shrine that houses the corpses of Borys’ twelve knights.

I suspect that the spirit of Borys lives on in the Black Opal upon his sarcophagus. Indeed, being immortal, when the sarcophagus was designed, this surely was some sort of magic jar spell to retain his living soul upon dead. Like a lich, he might now be able to swap souls with those who draw near to his tomb.

I speculate this is actually the case, and that Borys’ living soul (not undead) lives on in the Black Opal, so long as it survives. Though his Dragon’s body has been destroyed, I speculate that all his native wizardly skills and psionic powers remain. Upon reincarnation, he might quickly pursue dragon metamorphosis, and attempt to slowly return to something of his old self.

SeruZmaj argues that the spiritual conduit is tied to the soul of the Champion, and not to the energies of his Dark Lens empowered body. I could agree with this… so if so his ability to grant templar spells would remain. However, his body would be a mortal one, and I think he would have lost the ability to spellcast with ease, forming spells with no study and wielding psionic powers with no deep contemplations, as was the case for those who were empowered by the Dark Lens under the Steeple of Crystals.

In 2nd Edition terms, upon reincarnation in a suitable human body, I believe I would rate Borys to be a 20th level defiler / 20th level psionicist. He would have to regather spellbooks and learn all his spell anew to reaquaint himself with how a normal wizard must rememorize spells, and much contemplation and psionic study would be required to reharness all his powers as would a mortal, but he ultimately could do it. For clarity, I would deny him advanced levels (30/30), for these extra psionic skills, PSPs, spells and casting levels were simply too dependent upon his radically Dark Lens altered body, and he surely was far too used to wielding his powers as Sadira of Tyr can do so, without the need of any spellbook or hyper-extreme psionic discipline. He is reduced now to what his new mortal frame can hold and maintain.

And what would be his motives? His goals? Vengeance surely, on the Heroes of Tyr and probably Tyr in general. But he probably would also soon enough learn the nature of Rajaat’s new prison, and how comparatively weakly it is guarded by Sadira’s magic. The entirety of Ur Draxa once protected Rajaat’s prison, along with the might and magic of a fully metamorphosized 30th level dragon. Now, only the Cerulean Storm and Sadira’s 9th level spells guard Rajaat’s sun-prison. Borys would probably (and rightly) calculate this is a great risk, and work to imprison Rajaat more securely if he can.

Thoughts? Can Borys’ be reincarnated in your game? What powers would he have? What would he do? What would be his goals?

3 Likes

Hmmm. I think you may have seen this before…

1 Like

I think it’s a very plausible concept and perhaps relates to what we see in the Dragon Mag Dark Sun materials. There is to my reading of the novel a sort of implication that he has been swallowed by The Hollow or The Black, but there’s definitely room for his soul to have gone to said gem or perhaps be stuck beyond Athas proper

1 Like

Indeed Plortius. It is possible that his soul was captured and consumed by Rajaat and/or the Black, the Hollow Beneath the Black, etc. I could see that reading. But it is not explicit.

Denning deliberately put in the Black Opal… he indeed went well out of his way to put it in. Not to say that this magic jar was fool proof.

I have mixed feelings about it, to be sure. It really is a binary though, when you boil it down. Did Borys’ soul flee to the Black Opal, or is it dark and empty, after the events of The Cerulean Storm?

What say you?

2 Likes

According to The Valley of Dust and Fire, Borys is not so easily permanently defeated.

2 Likes

Given redking’s observation and a bit of thought I think it’s extremely likely Borys is in there. I’m not sure his body would be permanently gone though given what we know of the return of Andropinis after some centuries. Maybe his body is trapped in the Black or Hollow while his soul is jarred in the gem. Maybe he could posses the corpse of one of his former companions?

2 Likes

Rereading the pertinent passage from Cerulean Storm, it seems rather clear that Borys’ body at least died, and that this body was creepily transformed into a skeletal version of Rajaat before it burst apart into yet more black goo.

It reminds me how profoundly powerful Rajaat was. That black liquid within the Scourge was all but a death sentence if enough got on you. Even the Dragon seemed to not even stand a chance.

1 Like

I think it is likely that Borys’ soul was pulled into the Black or Hollow by Rajaat … but then released when the Dark Lens destroyed the Black Sphere. (And arguably destroyed the Hollow in the process, if Rajaat’s re-imprisonment is in the permanencied light spell. Though if the Hollow is non-existence, beyond the Black which separates “everything that exists from everything that does not”, then it can’t really be destroyed, and the light destroying the shadow in which Rajaat now exists would presumably drive him back into nothingness/the Hollow.)

So I think that after the end of Cerulean Storm his spirit/essence is likely in the black opal. Whether he’s a super - powered undead wraith or it’s a magic jar style setup is another question.

2 Likes

“Never say never”, especially when you’re dealing with extremely high level magic, and wizards who’ve had a lot of time to Batman their way out of problems.

“Reincarnation” raises interesting questions, because while he might have found a way out of the possible race change from reincarnation, he might not have, or being a dragon may have changed his soul in such a way at to prevent the change (I don’t subscribe to “once a dragon always a dragon” necessarily, but I don’t doubt it would be a hard condition to change).

Borys might work to contain Rajaat further, and that would probably be a concern, but consider that going to Ur Draxa puts him into Tithian’s sphere of influence, which I think he’d discern fairly quickly. How willing would he be to fight a sentient storm, bent on stopping him from reinforcing Rajaat’s prison?

TBH, I wouldn’t be surprised if he went the route of Dregoth and escaped to the planes; he might not seek godhood, but he would be smart and wise enough to realize a losing proposition. He was able to maintain the prison before because of a lot of infrastructure… cities giving him thousands of people to sacrifice to reinforce a prison prepared in advance. Now, he’s got none of that, and dealing with an ad hoc prison he had nothing to do with. Getting the hell out of Dodge, at least for a time, might be a good choice.

3 Likes

I believe that Rajaat’s black ooze perma killed both Borys and Abalach-Re, but for the sake of the argument, here’s my take on what would happen to Borys post CS-

Having being killed by Rajaat, three different forces immediately came into play trying to pull Borys’ soul to them:

  1. First and foremost, Rajaat’s ooze pulling borys soul towards the Black.
  2. Borys’s own contingencies, like clone bodies.
  3. The dark Opal on his sarcophagus.

As a result, borys soul is ripped at minimum into three (if not more) parts.

The main one is trapped at the border between the black and the hollow like Tithian, but unable to affect Athas at all

A second is at least one clone of his dragon body, but significantly less powerful and intelligent since his mind/souls is not all there.

The third is wraith Borys, who’s soul shard got pulled into the dark opal.

This leads to a “Reign of Supermen/Manshoon wars” type of situation where each souls shard is trying to gain dominance and consume the others.

I kind of like the idea of an adventure where several clone Boryses rampage across the Tyr region causing troubles all over, with wraith Borys manipulating the adventurers from behind the scenes to do his dirty work for him, and eventually direct them to try and free the rest of his soul from the Black, only for them to trick him and either destroy his soulgem or send the rest of his soul into imprisonment in the Black.

4 Likes

This seems like the intended meaning by Denning, that they were perma-killed. On immediate reading, it seems quite clear. Indeed, rather arguably, the black ooze consumed them both, soul and body. If this is the case, does this mean poor longsuffering Sa’ram suffered this fate as well?

The only hesitation in Borys’ case is the Black Opal, which Denning went out of his way to describe. We should just cut to the chase, and ask Denning if he meant to reincarnate Borys in some way.

2 Likes

That would be so sick :sign_of_the_horns:

1 Like

It could simply be that Denning thought that that was how Wraiths worked (a pre-set contingency for when you die) - all the other conceptual pieces of Athasian Wraiths are there (the gem to house the soul, arising after death, an actual wraith buddy right there, etc.)

Also, while i agee that Denning went out of his way to mention the Black Opal, you’re putting a lot of stock in the in-universe word of a wraith that thought the mul Rikus was the Dwarf-Butcher Borys of Ebe… She’s viewing everything she says though a particular lens, and doesn’t REALLY understand the situation.

1 Like

Yeah, i think the idea is that that is just how wraiths work in the Prism Pentad … Though I think it’s also implied that Rajaat was supposed to be able to raise them to real life rather than undeath, if things hadn’t gone down the way they did.

I agree the wraith doesn’t really understand the situation, but the gem as Borys’s soul receptacle itself seems to be real regardless - Rikus sees a row of gems only one of which isn’t ‘lit up’.

2 Likes